The Greatest Chocolate For Chocolate Chip Cookies » Hummingbird Excessive

photo of a tray of six cookies containing different kinds of chocolate

Table of Contents

What Is The Greatest Chocolate For Chocolate Chip Cookies?

I examined completely different sorts of chocolate to search out the perfect chocolate for chocolate chip cookie recipes! Chocolate is an important a part of any chocolate chip cookie recipe; your selection can have an effect on the flavour, texture, and even look of your cookies.

On this put up, I discover completely different flavors of chocolate (darkish versus milk versus white chocolate), shapes of chocolate (chips versus chunks versus chopped chocolate from a bar versus fèves), and rank a number of the hottest chocolate chip sorts. And right here’s what I discovered:

One of the best chocolate for chocolate for chocolate chip cookies is a darkish chocolate with between 60% to 70% cacao. For a bakery-style chocolate chip cookie that can bake large and flat, with picturesque specks and/or puddles and swimming pools of melted chocolate, use chopped chocolate from a high-quality baking bar like Ghirardelli and/or splurge on Valhrona fèves.

@hummingbirdhigh the perfect chocolate for #chocolatechipcookies! #bakingtiktok #baking101 ♬ The Great British Bake Off – Tom Howe

However let’s dig in:

Darkish, Milk, and White Chocolate In Cookies

You may customise any chocolate chip cookie recipe by utilizing completely different sorts of chocolate. Right here’s the professionals and cons of every selection:

photo showing the different colors of dark vs milk vs white chocolate chips
photo showing a tray of three cookies each with a different flavor of chocolate

Why You Ought to Use Darkish Chocolate In Chocolate Chip Cookies

Use a darkish chocolate that accommodates between 60% to 80% cacao for a traditional chocolate chip cookie. The bittersweet taste of the darkish chocolate balances out the sugars within the cookie dough, leading to a well-balanced, conventional chocolate chip cookie.

Darkish Chocolate Deep-Dive: What’s The Distinction Between Bittersweet and Semisweet Chocolate?

In the USA, there’s no official benchmark for the “bittersweet” and “semisweet” chocolate designations. It’s as much as producers to find out how a lot cocoa to make use of, and percentages will fluctuate tremendously from model to model. Due to this, I counsel you to disregard these bars and stick to a darkish chocolate that lists its cocoa proportion.

Like Ghirardelli! Though Ghirardelli sells a semi-sweet chocolate baking bar, additionally they promote a 60% cacao baking bar and a 70% cacao baking bar. These baking bars are simply present in most main supermarkets in the USA.

The Case For Utilizing Milk Chocolate In Chocolate Chip Cookies

In case you have a candy tooth, use a milk chocolate that accommodates between 35% to 45% cacao. Milk chocolate is sweeter in taste than darkish chocolate, and can end in a a lot sweeter cookie. If you wish to mood the sweetness of the milk chocolate, use half milk chocolate and half darkish chocolate.

The Case For Utilizing White Chocolate In Chocolate Chip Cookies

White chocolate doesn’t have any cocoa, and is the sweetest of the three candies. Though you should use it in any chocolate chip cookie recipe, the ensuing cookies will doubtless be too candy. I recommend pairing it with different flavorful substances like cocoa powder, warming spices, espresso and/or tea, or nuts to assist steadiness the cookie.

Try the next recipes for inspiration:

What about unsweetened chocolate?

Unsweetened chocolate is 100% cacao chocolate, with no added sugar. Of us like to make use of unsweetened chocolate in baking as a result of it can provide baked items a really intense chocolatey taste. Nevertheless, by itself, it may be fairly bitter.

When you don’t have a lot of a candy tooth, you should use unsweetened chocolate in your chocolate chip cookies. Nevertheless, I don’t suggest it for most individuals. Even with a candy cookie dough base, you’ll doubtless find yourself with chocolate chip cookies that aren’t as candy as you need them to be.

Chocolate Chips, Chunks, Bars, and Fèves In Cookies

It seems that the form of your chocolate is simply as necessary as the flavour you select. Typically, you should use the next kinds of chocolate in cookies:

  • chocolate chips
  • chocolate chunks
  • chopped chocolate from a baking bar
  • chocolate fèves
photo showing chocolate chips versus chunks versus a bar versus feves

Why You Ought to Use Chopped Chocolate OR Baking Fèves In Chocolate Chip Cookies

Each chocolate chips and chunks are designed to carry their form throughout the baking course of. Producers will both use extra cacao solids (which don’t soften as simply) and even add substances like paraffin wax or palm oil. These components can have an effect on the style of the chocolate. You may study extra in this Taste article (in which I’m quoted arguing against chocolate chips!).

To keep away from these extra substances in chocolate chips and chunks, I like to make use of both chocolate from a baking bar or chocolate fèves as an alternative. Baking bars and fèves don’t comprise any of the extra substances present in chips and chunks. As a substitute, they comprise extra cocoa butter. The cocoa butter makes the chocolate style richer and smoother, and permits it to soften extra simply when warmed. These translate to melt-in-your-mouth chocolate specks and/or swimming pools and melted puddles of chocolate in chocolate chip cookies!

What are chocolate fèves? Are they the identical factor as chocolate baking discs and wafers?

Chocolate fèves are a elaborate pastry college time period for a flat, bean-shaped disc of chocolate. When baked in a cookie recipe, the fèves don’t maintain their form (just like how chocolate chips usually do) and as an alternative soften into puddles. These puddles give your cookies skinny layers of chocolate all through each chunk. Essentially the most outstanding maker of chocolate fèves is considered one of my favourite chocolate makers, Valrhona Chocolate

photo of a bag of valrhona feves on a kitchen counter

Sadly, as a lot as I really like Valrhona chocolate, their chocolate fèves might be onerous to search out at your common grocery retailer. I usually purchase Valrhona merchandise on-line at AmazonKing Arthur Baking Company, or Valrhona’s online store. However in case you don’t need to purchase on-line, relaxation assured that different chocolate makers make related merchandise. Notably, Guittard Chocolate Company makes chocolate wafers. These wafers are just like fèves, however extra round in form. I’ve seen Guittard chocolate wafers at choose SafewayTarget, and Whole Foods shops.

What different chocolate do you suggest in addition to fèves?

When you can’t discover fèves, I additionally suggest Guittard Chocolate Wafers (that are extra available in most main supermarkets). When you’re on a finances, I like to recommend chopping up a Trader Joe’s Pound Plus bar or Ghirradelli baking chocolate bars as an alternative of chocolate chips. Both finely chop or roughly chop up the chocolate and use it within the chocolate chip cookie recipe of your selection!

Deep-Dive: The Distinction Between Roughly Chopped And Finely Chopped Chocolate

In order for you bigger swimming pools of chocolate in your cookie just like the style and look you’ll get when utilizing fèves, roughly chop the chocolate baking bar into 1- to 2- inch items. Doing so will end in chocolate chip cookies with big swimming pools and puddles of melted chocolate all through.

In order for you a extra speckled search for your cookies, finely chop the chocolate bar into ⅛-, ¼-, and ½-inch items. This methodology will end in a chocolate chip cookie with a “freckled” chocolate look, with a smoother mouthfeel with out the chocolate swimming pools of fèves.

GIF showing unbaked and baked cookies with roughly versus finely chopped chocolate

Do I really want to make use of chopped chocolate or fèves? Can I simply use chocolate chips?

If there’s one factor I need you to remove from this put up, it’s this: don’t skimp on chocolate! Most grocery retailer manufacturers—even those that supply merchandise particularly made for baking—comprise all types of components like paraffin wax and palm oil. These substances compromise the flavour and texture of your outcomes. I’ve stopped utilizing chocolate chips in 90% of my recipes, and my baked items have tasted so a lot better consequently. 

GIF showing baked vs unbaked versions of four cookies with different types of chocolate

The Case For Utilizing Chocolate Chips and Chunks

I admit there are nonetheless plenty of occasions during which it’s acceptable to make use of chocolate chips and chunks! I like to make use of chocolate chips and/or chunks after I’m craving a puffier chocolate chip cookie that tastes do-it-yourself, with distinct bites of small chocolate right here and there.

Listed below are different cases the place I like to make use of chocolate chips:

A Abstract Of How The Form Of The Chocolate Impacts Chocolate Chip Cookies

  • Chocolate Chips. Use chocolate chips if you would like your cookies to look do-it-yourself, with distinct, complete morsels and spherical items of chocolate all through the cookie. Chocolate chips additionally make puffier, thicker cookies that don’t unfold as a lot after they bake.
  • Chocolate Chunks. Most chocolate chunks are made utilizing the identical course of as chocolate chips. The one distinction is that they both are available sq./rectangular shapes (like Nestle Toll House), or jagged shards of chocolate (like Trader Joe’s).

    Just like the case for chocolate chips, use chocolate chunks if you would like your cookies to look do-it-yourself. They’ll have distinct, complete items of rectangular-shaped chocolate all through. As a result of the chunks received’t soften throughout the baking course of, utilizing them will end in puffier, thicker cookies.

  • Chopped Chocolate From A Baking Bar. Not like chocolate chips and chunks, chopped chocolate melts when baked, resulting in melty specks and swimming pools of chocolate within the cookies.

    Use chopped chocolate if you would like knowledgeable wanting chocolate chip cookie that appears prefer it was made by a bakery. In order for you bigger swimming pools of chocolate in your cookie, roughly chop the chocolate bar into 1- to 2- inch items. In order for you a extra speckled search for your cookies, finely chop the chocolate bar into ⅛-, ¼-, and ½-inch items.

  • Chocolate Fèves. Chocolate fèves (or discs or wafers) are made with the identical chocolate as baking bars. I like to think about them as pre-chopped baking bars which are already the right form and dimension for creating big swimming pools of chocolate in chocolate chip cookies.

    Use chocolate fèves if you would like knowledgeable wanting chocolate chip cookie that appears prefer it was made by a bakery. They make large cookies which are filled with layers of swimming pools and puddles of melted chocolate.

@hummingbirdhigh chips vs chunks vs bars vs fèves!!! #chocolatechipcookies #baking #bakingtiktok ♬ The Great British Bake Off – Tom Howe

The Greatest Chocolate Chips For Any Baking Recipe

Not all chocolate chips are created equal. Some comprise extra cacao solids and/or synthetic components that negatively have an effect on the style of the chocolate.

I examined 4 standard manufacturers and located my favourite selection within the TikTok video under. Though there are extra chocolate chip manufacturers and kinds obtainable, I selected chocolate chip manufacturers that listed their cacao percentages on the packages to begin with:

@hummingbirdhigh style testing all the perfect chocolate chips so that you don’t need to! #chocolatechipcookies #easyrecipes #lifeadvice #cookinghacks #baking ♬ Patisserie Skills – Tom Howe

The TL/DR of the video:

  • Ghirardelli Bittersweet 60% Cacao Chocolate Chips. These chocolate chips truly melted fairly equally to chopped chocolate bars and/or fèves, and tasted nice. They’re formed flatter and wider than different chocolate chips, leading to flatter cookies that unfold generously within the oven. They’re the chocolate chips I normally inventory in my pantry as they’re available in most main grocery shops.
  • Guittard 63% Extra Dark Chocolate Chips. I appreciated the best way these chocolate chips tasted on their very own. In my view, they tasted finest and I might fortunately snack on them eternally. However didn’t like how they baked in my chocolate chip cookie recipe. They soften in any respect and maintained their form all through the baking course of, resulting in additional puffy and chunky textured cookies.
  • Nestle Toll House 53% Chocolate Morsels. Of all of the chips I attempted, these had the worst taste and texture. They tasted the least chocolatey and had a bizarre, waxy shine and really feel. Their solely benefit is that they cooled shortly, permitting you to retailer the cookies sooner.
  • Dealer Joe’s 72% Cacao Chocolate Chips. I used to be tremendous impressed with these chocolate chips. Just like Ghirardelli, they tasted nice and melted like chopped chocolate and/or fèves. Just like Ghirardelli, they’re flatter and wider than the opposite chocolate chips on this record. Their solely drawback is you could solely purchase them at Dealer Joe’s.

My Greatest Simple Chocolate Chip Cookie Recipe

My Greatest Simple Chocolate Chip Cookie Recipe makes cookies which are chewy and fudgy within the middle, whereas crispy on the perimeters. The cookie dough solely takes 5 minutes to make because you needn’t use a stand mixer or chill the dough.

A photo of chocolate chip cookies on a gold sheet pan.

Small Batch Chocolate Chip Cookie Recipe

These small batch chocolate chip cookies are chewy within the middle, crispy of their edges, and crammed with plenty of chocolate puddles! One of the best half? You may customise this small batch recipe to make both 4 massive cookies or 6 medium ones!

Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookies Recipe

These pumpkin chocolate chip cookies are NOT cakey. As a substitute, they’re crispy on the perimeters, chewy and fudgy of their facilities, and crammed with swimming pools of chocolate—similar to your favourite chocolate chip cookies!

Chocolate Chip Cookies With Powdered Sugar Recipe

Chocolate chip cookies with powdered sugar are a novel twist on the traditional chocolate chip cookie recipe! The powdered sugar within the recipe helps soak up moisture from different substances, giving the cookies an additional tender and chewy texture.

My Greatest Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie Recipe

My finest oatmeal chocolate chip cookie recipe makes cookies which are chewy within the center, crisp within the middle, and crammed with plenty of crunchy oatmeal and swimming pools of melted chocolate!

best oatmeal chocolate chip cookie recipe
toll house chocolate chip cookie recipe

My Greatest Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake Recipe

My finest chocolate chip cookie cake recipe makes an enormous, 10-inch chocolate chip cookie with a fudgy middle and crisp edges. The chocolate chip cookie cake is adorned with a traditional American buttercream frosting and many sprinkles. All in all, it tastes just like the chocolate chip cookie truffles you bear in mind from childhood!

covid chocolate chip cookie cake

Vegan Tahini Chocolate Chip Cookie Recipe

These vegan chocolate chip cookies style EXACTLY like common chocolate chip cookies with crisp edges, gentle and chewy facilities, and swimming pools of molten darkish chocolate all through each chunk of cookie. That is all because of a handful of “secret” substances like tahini, coconut oil, and vegan chocolate.

vegan tahini chocolate chip cookies

S’mores Chocolate Chip Cookie Recipe

This s’mores chocolate chip cookie recipe is the cookie model of a traditional s’mores deal with! Suppose: cookies filled with swimming pools of melted chocolate, crunchy graham cracker crumbs, and gooey melted marshmallows.

Brown Butter Toffee Chocolate Chip Cookie Recipe

These brown butter and toffee chocolate chip cookies are the chocolate chip cookies you recognize and love, however LEVELED UP! These brown butter toffee chocolate chip cookies are made with milk chocolate and Skor toffee items.

brown butter toffee chocolate chip cookies

Earl Gray Chocolate Chip Cookie Recipe

Improve a traditional chocolate chip cookie recipe with Earl Gray tea! These Earl Gray chocolate chip cookies are infused with Earl Gray. The tea enhances the darkish chocolate and provides the cookies a novel, floral style and aroma.

Earl Grey chocolate chip cookies

My Greatest M&M Cookie Recipe

M&M chocolate candies are a enjoyable, whimsical means so as to add completely different textures and flavors to traditional chocolate chip cookies. When the M&M cookies are heat and contemporary from the oven, the M&Ms burst with molten chocolate and crispy textures with each chunk!


Over the previous a number of years of operating Hummingbird Excessive, I saved a vital side of my life hidden from my readers: I had a full-time, extraordinarily demanding job within the tech world. In my debut cookbook, Weeknight Baking, I lastly reveal the secrets and techniques to baking scrumptious desserts on a decent schedule.